Genshin Impact

Lyney Trial Answers Guide

Genshin Impact - Participate in the Trial Banner

Lyney's Trial requires you to answer several loopholes to refute Furina during Chapter 4, Act 1 of Genshin Impact. Read on to learn how to answer the loopholes, refute accusations, and create the right Logic Chains in this guide!

Lyney's Trial Answers - Loopholes and Refutations

Refutation and Trial Sequence

Order Click to jump to a section!
1st 1st Refutation
2nd 1st Logic Chain
3rd 2nd Logic Chain
4th 3rd Logic Chain
5th 2nd Refutation

Traveler will have to defend Lyney in his trial, with the Hydro Archon, Lady Furina across the opera house as the prosecutor. There will be a First Refutation, followed by three Logic Chains, and lastly the Second Refutation.

They must defend Lyney by finding loopholes in the Hydro Archon's retelling of the events, and then select the evidence to refute using information collected before the trial!

First Refutation Walkthrough

Genshin Impact - Lady Furina

In the first refutation, help convince the audience and Oratrice by refuting Furina's accusations against Lyney!

How to Win the First Refutation

Statement Refute With
1 Lyney entered the tunnel nothing
2 Lyney attacked Halsey Lyney's Statement
3 Lyney kidnapped Halsey Lyney Heard a Voice to the Oratrice
4 Lyney knocked Cowell out The Young Lady's Clothes
5 Onstage Accident nothing

Follow-up Question - Evidence that Lyney Wasn't in the Tunnel

Genshin Impact - Answering Furina

After this Refuting, Lady Furina follows with a question, asking what is the evidence that Lyney wasn't in the tunnel when the crime took place.

The Court Record opens automatically, and the Traveler must select Strange Sound During the Magic Show, and Paimon explains how afterwards.

Who was the Murderer Logic Chain

Genshin - Lyney

The first Logic Chain would require you infer who the True Culprit is, based on the evidences you've gathered so far!

How to Win the First Logic Chain

Statement Refute With
1 How did the culprit trigger the onstage accident? Gardes Investigation Report
2 What was the original plan for the performance? The Magic Trick
3 What evidence is there that the selected audience member was involved the incident? The Young Lady's Clothes
4 Who is the True Culprit? Cowell

Recreate What Cowell Did Logic Chain

Genshin - Lyney

The second Logic Chain requires you to recreate what Cowell did based on the current evidences you have!

How to Win the Second Logic Chain

Statement Refute With
1 How Can we Envisage Lyney as Having been Unable to Interfere with the Crime? Lyney's Statement
2 How Can I Prove There was an Altercation at the Tunnel? Strange Sound During the Magic Show
3 Who is the Prime Suspect Currently? The Deceased's Identity
4 Where did the missing Halsey go? Broken Flower Vase

The Traveler Actually Cannot Solve One of the Questions At First

Genshin Impact - Paimon Giving Traveler A New Idea
There's a reason players cannot properly clear the second Logic Chain when tackling it the first time; the game did not give enough clues through the context of the story.

You have to fail to actually progress first, before the proper answer of the Broken Flower Vase can actually be picked.

Reconstruct the Criminal's Plan Logic Chain

Genshin - Lyney

For the third Logic Chain, you'll still required to reconstruct the criminal's plan, but this time you have now better and stronger evidences, given that you've just obtained Water from the Primordial Sea!

How to Win the Second Logic Chain

Statement Refute With
1 Who is the Prime Suspect Currently? The Deceased's Identity
2 What item did the culprit use to control the timing of the dissolution? Dropped Hook Rope
3 What item did the culprit use to dissolve Halsey? Water from the Primordial Sea
4 What item did the culprit use to hide the mechanism behind the crime? Audience-Side Magic Box Structure

Second Refutation Walkthrough

Genshin Impact - Lady Furina

For the second refutation, you have to convince the audience and the Oratrice that Lyney has been framed for possessing the Water from the Primordial Sea among his personal effects!

How to Win the Second Refutation

Statement Refute With
1 Lyney entered the tunnel nothing
2 Halsey Dissolved Strange Sound During the Magic Show
3 Infighting between Lyney and Cowell Broken Flower Vase
4 Lyney knocked Cowell out The Young Lady's Clothes
5 Onstage Accident nothing

How to Prepare to Participate in the Trial

Collect Evidence

Genshin Impact - Fontaine Opera House Investigation Banner

The Traveler had already started collecting evidence to defend Lyney when they were collecting clues inside the opera house in a previous mission. Take advantage of the Court Records and the Perception Skill to prepare for the trial as much as you can!

How to Look for Clues Inside the Opera House

How to Participate in the Trial Information

Objective in Fontaine Archon Quest Act 1

Genshin Impact - Opera House Cutscene feat. Lyney

You can Participate in the Trial during the Archon Quest Chapter 4, Act 1 of Genshin Impact's Main Story.

Chapter 4: Act I Archon Quest Guide

Genshin Impact Related Guides

All Tips and Tricks Guides

Genshin Impact - Tips and Tricks

All Tips & Tricks Guides

Before Starting The Game

Element Guides

Leveling and Grinding Guides

Tips to Remember

Miscellaneous Guides

FAQs

Comment

4 Anonymousabout 1 year

it did work, just read properly you idiot

3 Anonymousabout 1 year

lmao wow okay it was in the next sequence nvm

    Walkthrough Menu

    Please participate in our
    site improvement survey 11/2024
    Would you assist in
    improving Game8's site?
    ×
    This survey will take about 1 minute.
    Your answers will help us to improve our website.
    We are listening to our users' valuable opinions and discussing how to act on them.
    The information collected through this survey will be used for the purpose of improving our services. In addition, the information will only be disclosed a part of a statistic in a format that will not allow identification of personal information.
    Begin Survey

    All rights reserved