Turning in Sebastian will affect whether or not Sebastian appears at the end of the main story in Hogwarts Legacy. Find out if you should turn in Sebastian or not and all results of turning in Sebastian during In the Shadow of Fate.

All Sebastian Choice Results

Affects Whether You See Sebastian Again

If you select We should turn Sebastian in the first time, you'll be given the option to change your mind after Ominis tells you that you may never see him again. That, in fact, is what happens so think hard before you make the decision.

In the Shadow of Fate Side Quest Walkthrough

Should You Turn in Sebastian?

Preferably Don't Turn in Sebastian

The choice affects whether Sebastian appears in the ending of the main story and in the final quest to conclude his questline, In the Shadow of Friendship. If you turn him in, Ominis will take his role in those aforementioned concluding scenes.

Sebastian can still teach you the curses

If you don't learn the Unforgivable Curses during their respective quests, you can still learn them from Sebastian by talking to him in the Undercroft. Consequently, if you turn Sebastian in, then he will no longer show up in the Undercroft to teach you the curses.

Think carefully about the decision to turn him in, if you're still undecided about learning the curses.

How to Get All Unforgivable Curses

What happens to Sebastian?

Given that Sebastian is remorseful and will have to live with both the guilt and being estranged from his twin sister, you can choose to not turn him in so that he's present at the conclusion of both the main story and of his own questline. This makes both story feel more well-rounded, as opposed to just getting a status update from Ominis at the end.

Hogwarts Legacy Related Guides

List of Choices

Choices and Consequences Guides