Hogwarts Legacy

Should You Tell Claire Beaumont the Truth?

Hogwarts Legacy Tell Claire

Telling Claire Beaumont the truth doesn't affect the ending of the quest Brother's Keeper in Hogwarts Legacy. Find out if you should tell Claire the truth and all outcomes of the Claire truth choice!

All Claire Truth Outcomes

Choice Result
I'm afraid he's dead. You tell Claire that Bardolph turned into an Inferius and that you had to kill him.
He's decided to pursue a new life. You tell Claire that Bardolph joined the Ashwinders.

The choice occurs at the end of the quest Brother's Keeper, but it doesn't affect the ending nor the rewards received.

Brother's Keeper Side Quest Walkthrough

Should You Tell Claire the Truth?

Choice Doesn't Change Outcome

Hogwarts Legacy Claire Beaumont

You can choose either option, because whether you tell Claire the truth or lie, both choices result in Claire being devastated at the news you bring her.

Claire is heartbroken over both dialogue options and even has the exact same final line: "What more could I have done? Oh, Bardolph."

Hogwarts Legacy Related Guides

Hogwarts Legacy Choices

List of Choices

Choices and Consequences Guides

Choices Guides
Tell Weasley the Truth? Natty or Sebastian?
Get the Fwooper Feather? Tell Natty the Truth?
Tell Claire the Truth? Tell Sebastian the Truth?
Who Should Cast Crucio? Take the Relic?
Side with Ominis or Sebastian? Should You Talk to the Centaurs?
What is the Black Family Motto? Should You Burn Ferdinand’s Frame?
Kneel or Attack the Graphorn? Learn Avada Kedavra?
Turn In Sebastian? Keep the Repository Contained or Open it?
Should You Free Penny?

Author

    Walkthrough Menu

    All rights reserved