A Wish for a Fish Sidequest Guide | Should You Spare or Kill King Frost?

This is a full walkthrough and guide for A Wish for a Fish sidequest in Shin Megami Tensei V (SMT 5). Read on to figure out where to find the sidequest, how to complete it, and what rewards you can receive.

A Wish for a Fish Quest Location

Relevant Locations
A Wish for a Fish Quest Giver	King Frost Location

This quest can be accessed immediately after the boss fight against Loup-garou near the Container Yard Leyline. The quest giver will be a Nekotama NPC.

A Wish for a Fish Sidequest Information

How to Complete A Wish for a Fish

Objectives
1	Find Nekomata near the Container Yard Leyline after the Loup-garou boss fight.
2	Go back to the Container Yard Leyline and drop down to the rooftop. Head Southeast on the map and and drop down to the lower level. Enter the building to find King Frost.
3	King Frost recognizes that you have come to steal his fish and defends himself. Defeat King Frost. Note: Whichever choice you make after the fight, you will still recieve the fish and unlock King Frost for fusion.
4	Report back to Nekotama for quest rewards and to unlock King Frost for special fusion.

How to Beat King Frost

King Frost is weak to Fire and Dark-type skills, and uses Ice-type skills. We recommend being at least level 28 and bringing a team of Kikuri-Hime, Cironnup, and Jack Frost to handle this battle.

Jack Frost Absorbs Ice magic which means King Frost will lose a turn if Jack Frost is targeted with an Ice skill. Cironnup has access to Fire-type skills which are great for some DPS. Kikuri-Hime will be your primary healer but can also work as a mixed attacker if she has access to Agi or a higher level version of it.

How to Beat King Frost Boss Guide

Should You Spare or Kill King Frost?

Sparing Him Completes the Quest

If you spare King Frost, he will give you the fish and you can complete the quest by reporting back to Nekotama. You will recieve the Beast Talisman and unlock King Frost's fusion upon reporting to Nekotama regardless.

Killing Him Completes the Quest

If you choose to kill King Frost, he will disappear and you will recieve the fish to complete the quest. You will recieve the Beast Talisman and unlock King Frost's fusion upon reporting to Nekotama regardless.

Shin Megami Tensei V Related Guides

List of Subquests and Rewards

Vengeance Subquests

Subquests
Prince of Her Dreams	In Pursuit of Knowledge
Brawny Ambitions	She Who Rules the Night
Knocking on Death's Door	Beastly Battle of Wits
Home Sweet Home	To New Horizons
Picture-Perfect Debut	Essential Research
Brawny Ambitions II	Infiltrate the Demon Feast
Tough Love	Pixie on the Case
As God Wills	A Self of My Own
Part-Time Gasser	Lighting the Way
Reclaim the Golden Stool	Liberate the Golden Stool
A Star is Born	Shinjuku Jewel Hunt
The Disgraced Bird God	The Vampire in Black
The Hunter in White	Alice's Wonderland
Devotion to Order	Heroes of Heaven and Earth
The Serpent King	The Great Adversary
Supersonic Racing	Classified Courier
Song of Nostalgia	Guide to the Lost
Rite of Resurrection	Heroes of the Celts
The Guardian of Light

List of SMTV Vengeance Subquests

Da'at: Minato

Subquests
A Preta Predicament	No Stone Unturned
Bully Breaker	Pollution Panic
The Spirit of Love	The Water Nymph
The Cursed Mermaids	The Demon of the Spring
To Cure a Curse	The Gold Dragon's Arrival
The Benevolent One	The Ultimate Omelette
Talisman Hunt	Movin' on Up
Keeper of the West	The Succession of Ra

Da'at: Shinagawa

Subquests
Chakra Drop Chomp	Those Seeking Sanctuary
Holding the Line	A Wish for a Fish
Magic from the East	Can I Keep Them?
Iced Out	Kumbhanda's Bottle
Birds of a Feather	The Tyrant of Tennozu
The Root of the Problem	A Goddess Stolen
The One I Love	The Falcon's Head
Keeper of the South

Da'at: Chiyoda

Subquests
The Path to Myojin Forest	Lighting the Way
Black Frost Strikes Back	A Sobering Standoff
Stones of Malice	One Mokoi's Trash...
He of a Hundred Hands	An Unusual Forecast
A Power Beyond Control	The Search for Oyamatsumi
Clash with the Kunitsukami	The Horn of Plenty
Roar of Hatred	Glitter in Ginza
The Angel of Destruction	The Ancient Guardian
Keeper of the East

Da'at: Taito

Subquests
On Bended Knees	Downtown Rock 'n Roll
The Egyptians' Fate	A Princess in a Pickle
In Defense of Tokyo	The Raid on Tokyo
A Need for Nectar	Abaddon's Assault
Keeper of the North	The Bull God's Lineage
An Incentive for Incense	The Destined Leader
The Holy Ring	The Sleeping Sands
The Winged Sun	Fionn's Resolve
A Universe in Peril

Empyrean

Subquests
The Seraph's Return	The Red Dragon's Invitation
The Noble Queen	The Wrathful Queen
The Compassionate Queen	A Plot Revealed

DLC Quests

DLC Subquests
A Goddess in Training	The Doctor's Last Wish
The Rage of a Queen	Return of the True Demon
Sakura Cinders of the East	Holy Will and Profane Dissent