In Honkai: Star Rail, Players will have to Debate with Butler in order to help Peppy obtain the stolen Curio! Check out which evidence to present, what statements are lies, and how to help Peppy locate the stolen curio!

Critter Pick Event Guides
Lifeform Oven	Rare Creations	Peppy Guide

How to Win the Debate With Butler

First Statement and Evidence

• Statement: Your claim of me behaving immorally, deliberately locking the door to trap everyone here is laughable. The access control switch is installed so high that I can't even reach it!
• Evidence: Abnormal images from surveillance records.

The first evidence you will be using against Butler will be the Abnormal images from surveillance records. Use it when Butler is denying claims that they could have never reached the access control switch.

Second Statement and Evidence

• Statement: How unique am I as a fellow Ruan Mei's creation? For example, Miss Ruan Mei does not wish for me to be affected by lowly physical needs, so I do not even need to eat!
• Evidence: Cosmic Fried Rice (Overnight Edition).

The second statement will have you use the Cosmic Fried Rice (Overnight Edition). You can get this by giving Ruan Mei's Gourmand Creation a Freshly-Baked Cake, which you can get by interacting with the pastry on one of the tables.

Give the critter the pastry, and it will point you to where the Cosmic Fried Rice (Overnight Edition) is located. Getting the fried rice will allow you to finally start the debate with Butler!

Final Statement and Evidence

• Statement: She and I have always communicated through the terminal. She entrusts me to manage everyone. I've reported everyone's performance to her, and she is very pleased with me.
• Evidence: External communication records.

The final evidence you will be using will be the External communication records, which you can get by interacting with the terminal near Butler.

Doing so will effectively expose Butler's final lie and allow you to win this debate!

How to Unlock the Butler Debate

Finish It All Started With a Man and a Dog (III)

The debate with Butler can only be accessed from Difficulty 3 once you've finished Difficulty 1 and 2 from the It All Started With a Man and a Dog Warring Expeditions.

You have to gather all the evidence first before you can start the debate with Butler!

Peppy Interlude and Exploration Guide

Honkai: Star Rail Related Guides

Critter Pick Event Guide

Critter Pick Main Highlights

Main Event Highlights
Lifeform Oven	Rare Creations	Peppy Guide

Critter Pick Guides and Quests

All Critter Prick Guides
Nurture Quest	Care Quest
Reunion Quest	How to Debate with Butler
Tame-A-Gotcha Is Hungry Achievement	The Cat in the Hat Achievement
Accommodation Achievements

Other Upcoming and Current Events

All Events and Schedules