Super Mario RPG

Should You Confess to Stealing the Treasures in Rose Town?

Super Mario RPG Remake - Should You Confess to Stealing the Treasures in Rose Town?

This is a guide on the Rose Town side quest on whether you should confess to stealing a Toad's treasure in Super Mario RPG Remake. Learn about whether you should confess, all possible order of actions and its rewards, and the best way to confess!

Should You Confess to Stealing Treasures?

Get Both Forest Maze Secret Path and House Treasures Before Confessing

Confessing is the best thing to do. But it will need to be done following specific instructions below will lead to the best outcome of this event, which involves following the Forest Maze Secret Path first, stealing the treasures after, and finally confessing to stealing them. Make sure to follow them carefully or else the rewards outcome will be altered!

This route rewards the most Frog Coins which are used to buy valuable items from the Frog Coin Emporium in Tadpole Pond and rare equipment from the Frog Coin Shop in Seaside Town.

▼Jump to Forest Maze Secret Path Directions

All Possible Orders and Rewards

All Orders of Actions to Follow and Rewards

All Possible Orders to Follow | Rewards
Order #1 1. Go to House & Steal Treasures
2. Deny Stealing Treasures
3. Go to Forest & Get Treasures
• Frog Coin x1
• Flower Chest x3
• Mushroom Chest x3
Order #2 1. Go to House & Steal Treasures
2. Admit to Stealing Treasures
3. Go to Forest & Get Treasures
• Frog Coin x1
• Flower Chest x3
• Mushroom Chest x3
Order #3 1. Go to House & Don't Steal Treasures
2. Take Chests after the Toad Enters the House
3. Go to Forest & get Treasures
• Frog Coin x1
• Flower Chest x3
• Mushroom Chest x1
• Coins x13
Order #4 1. Go to Forest & Get Treasures
2. Go to House & Steal Treasures
3. Deny Stealing Treasures
• Frog Coin x1
• Flower Chest x5
• Mushroom Chest x1
Order #5
(Best Order)
1. Go to Forest & Get Treasures
2. Go to House & Steal Treasures
3. Admit to Stealing Treasures
Frog Coin x2
Flower Chest x5
Mushroom Chest x1
Order #6 1. Go to Forest & Get Treasures
2. Go to House & Don't Steal Treasures
3. Take Chests After the Toad Enters the House
• Frog Coin x2
• Flower Chest x3
• Mushroom Chest x1
• Coins x13

*Having multiple Mushroom chests won't do anything since you'd only ever need one to fully recover, so outcomes with multiple of these are comparatively bad results.

5th Order is the Best Order to Follow

Following the 5th order listed above, wherein you'll begin collecting all the treasures in the Forest Maze, then proceeding to the house to gather all the treasures from the chests there, and finally allowing the Toad to enter the house and confess to stealing the treasures, will result in the best possible rewards.

Again, diverging from the route above will alter rewards, such as preventing the Treasure Hunter from giving you an extra Frog Coin.

How to Get the Best Rewards

Forest Maze Directions
(Starting from Maze Area Save Point)
Obtain Forest Maze Treasures
Enter the Elevated House
Take the Flowers
Press the Green Button to Enable Stairway
Confess to Stealing the Treasure

Obtain Forest Maze Treasures

Forest Maze Directions
(Starting from Maze Area Save Point)
Enter Upper-Left Exit
Enter Lower-Left Exit
Enter Lower-Left Ext
Enter Upper-Left Exit
Return to Rose Town
(Repeatedly Take Lower-Left Exits)
Forest Maze Treasures
Flower Chest x3
Frog Coin x1
Mushroom Chest x1

Proceed to through the Forest Maze and follow the directions above. Entering the last exit will lead Mario to the Treasure Room.

Obtain the treasures in the room and return to Rose Town. One quick way to exit the maze when lost is by taking the Lower-Left Exits, which usually sends Mario back to the maze entrance.

Enter the Elevated House

In Rose Town, there will be a Toad, a Treasure Hunter, walking beside an elevated patch land who will ask Mario to help him get to his house.

To climb up to the house, jump on top of the Toad and then jump onto the elevated land. Go inside and there will be two Treasure Boxes, each containing a Flower.

At second floor of the house is Treasure Hunter's son and a green button that activates a stairway for the Treasure Hunter. Do not press this button yet as it will change the reward outcome.

Take the Flowers

Open the chests and take the Flowers, then exit the house without talking to Treasure Hunter.

If you lower the staircase for the Treasure hunter by pressing down the green button at the second floor, you will be forced to answer his question about his Treasure Boxes.

Press the Green Button to Enable Stairway

Climb the up the Treasure Hunter's house through the same method again (by jumping on the Toad), enter the building and go up the second floor.

Press the green button in this room to enable the stairway for the Treasure Hunter, then head outside trigger the Treasure Hunter's dialogue.

Confess to Stealing the Treasure

Super Mario RPG Get Frog Coin from Toad in Rose Town.jpg

Dialogue Options
When asked if his Treasures are okay.
Choose: "I wouldn't say so."
In response to the Treasure Hunter going out after checking.
Choose "Sorry, I got carried away."

Follow the dialogue options above and the Treasure Hunter will accept your confession. He will be impressed that you have found the treasures in the Forest Maze without his help, and will give you a Frog Coin.

If you let the Toad into his house before getting the Forest Maze treasures, he will give you a hint for where to find the treasure (if you confess to stealing the treasure or refrain from stealing them), and he will not give you a Frog Coin even after you find the Forest Maze treasure.

Super Mario RPG Remake Related Guides

Super Mario RPG - Return to Top Page

Super Mario RPG Remake Top Page

Super Mario RPG Remake Categories

All Categories
Super Mario RPG - WalkthroughWalkthrough Super Mario RPG - CharactersCharacters
Super Mario RPG Remake - BossesBosses Super Mario RPG Remake - Maps and LocationsMaps and Locations
Super Mario RPG Remake - WeaponsWeapons Super Mario RPG Remake - ArmorArmor
Super Mario RPG Remake - AccessoriesAccessories Super Mario RPG - ItemsItems
Super Mario RPG - Special MovesSpecial Moves Super Mario RPG Remake - EnemiesEnemies and Monster List
Super Mario RPG - Enemy AttacksEnemy Attacks Super Mario RPG Remake - Hidden Treasure ChestsHidden Treasure Chests

Super Mario RPG Remake Tips and Tricks

Gameplay Tips and Tricks
Beginner's Guide Best Strategy to Win Battles
How Long to Beat All Missables and Choices
What to Spend Frog Coins On How to Block Attacks and Timing
Action Command Timing for Special Moves List of All Equipment
All Shops and Locations How to Get a Freebie
List of All Side Quests Language Settings and How to Change Language
How to Save and Turn Off Autosave -
New Features
Changes from the Original Game Sound Player and How to Unlock
Breezy Mode and Difficulty Settings Storage Box
Monster List: How to Check Enemy Stats List of Triple Move Attacks
How to Fill the Action Gauge Fast All Toad Assist Bonuses and Best Bonus
How to Fast Travel Special Enemies Explained
List of Ally Buffs -
Best Guides and Tier Lists
Character Tier List Best Party
Best Weapons Best Armor
Best Accessories Best Equipment
Best Special Moves Best Triple Moves
Post-Game Guides
All Post-Game Equipment All Post-Game Content and How to Get 100% Clear
All Post-Game Boss Rematches and How to Unlock How to Get All Gold Medals in the Play Report
How to Use Stay Vouchers -
Farming Guides
How to Farm EXP How to Farm Coins
How to Farm Frog Coins How to Farm Flower Points
Rare Items and Collectibles
List of All Collectibles All Hidden Chest Locations
Invincibility Star Locations Mushroom Kingdom Hidden Chest
Belome Temple Treasure Room Key Location 3 Musty Fears Flag Locations
How to Get the Lazy Shell Armor and Weapon All Flower Locations
How to Get Last Forest Maze Hidden Chest -
Secrets and Easter Eggs
All Secrets and Easter Eggs What is Peach's ???
What Does the Mushroom Kingdom Inn Kid Do? How to Get Fat Yoshi
All Wishes on Star Hill How to Open the Door in Monstro Town
What Does the Dream Cushion Do? How to Get the Secret Ending
Samus Cameo and How to Find Link Cameo and How to Find
How to Promote Apprentices -
FAQs and Tricky Points
What is the Max Flower Points Total? What is the Max Level?
Can You Increase Max Coins? Can You Increase Inventory Size?
How to Go Into Pipes Should You Give Back the Wallet?
Should You Confess to Stealing Treasures? Booster Tower Trap Room Guide
Where to Get Frogfucius's Snack How to Knock Down the Marrymore Church Door
Should You Give the Star to Speardovich? How to Duck and Slide to Get the Pipe Vault Frog Coin
Super Mario RPG Remake Review: Is it Worth It? Can You Respec?
How to Get Secret Chest in Kero Sewers Can You Get the 7th Star Piece?
What Happens When You Die? -
Useful NPCs
Frog Coin Emporium Items and How to Get All Cards Moleville Swap Shop: What to Trade Points For
Treasure Hunting Toad Guide Mushroom Boy Shop: All Rare Mushrooms

Super Mario RPG Minigames

All Minigame Guides
Midas River Goomba Thumping
Yoshi Racing (Mushroom Derby) Mine Car (Moleville Mountain)
Beetle Mania Yoshi Egg (Wheeere's Yoshi?!)
Booster Hill Booster Family Order
Sky Bridge Paratroopa Cliff Scale
Melody Bay Tadpole Songs Belome Temple Fortune
Sunken Ship Puzzles Sunken Ship Password
Knife Guy's Juggling Game Grate Guy's Casino
Marrymore Hotel Bellhop Minigame Marrymore Wedding
Dodo Statue Curtain Minigame
6 Doors (Bowser's Keep Trial Course) Bowser's Keep Action Course
Bowser's Keep Battle Course Bowser's Keep Puzzle Course
Dr. Topper Quiz Barrel Counting Puzzle
Triathlon Puzzle Coin Collecting Puzzle
Magic Buttons Puzzle Ball Solitaire Puzzle
Message Boards
Minigame Records Board -

List of All Minigames and Rewards

Super Mario RPG Game Mechanics

Game Mechanics and Stat Guides
All Characters by Stats Stats Explained
Level Up Bonus Explained Bonus Flower Effects and How to Get
How to Flee From Battle List of Controls
Element Guides
Element Explained and List of Moves by Element Jump Moves
Fire Moves Thunder Moves
Ice Moves Neutral Moves
Status Effect Guides
List of Status Conditions Sleep
Poison Fear
Mute Mushroom
Scarecrow -

All News Articles

Author

    Walkthrough Menu

    news questionnaire

    All rights reserved