An Eye for an Eye Walkthrough, Choices and Best Choice
Looking to get more ability points? See the locations for all Places of Power here:
・Place of Power Locations
Trying to make more coin as quickly as possible? See our Money Making Guide!
・How to Make Money Fast
Want to know the best early game builds and skills to invest in? We've got you covered!
・Best Early Game Skills and Builds
This is a guide to the quest titled An Eye for an Eye from The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Read on to learn locations, rewards, best choices, best outcomes, as well as useful tips, strategy for completing this quest, choices and best choice to choose from.
| Previous Quest | Current Quest | Next Quest |
|---|---|---|
| - | An Eye for an Eye | - |
List of Contents
An Eye for an Eye Location and Rewards
Basic Information
| Quest Number | - |
|---|---|
| Region | Novigrad |
| Quest Location | Hanged Man's Tree Temerian Partisan hideout |
| Previous Quest | - |
| Next Quest | - |
Rewards
| Gold Reward | None |
|---|---|
| Exp Reward | None |
| Item Reward | None |
How to Unlock An Eye for an Eye
You unlock this quest during the main quest Get Junior after speaking to Radovid at the chess club.
Is An Eye for an Eye Missable or Failable?
This quest will fail after reaching The Isle of Mists or if during the An Eye for an Eye, the player fails to save Ves.
An Eye for an Eye Walkthrough
| Objectives | |
|---|---|
| 1 | Talk to Roche at the Temarian Partisan Camp, located north east of Oxenfurt. |
| 2 | Talk to Roche standing right next to the Hang Man's Tree. |
| 3 | Run to Murlbrydale south of Hanged Man's Tree. Ves can die to the Nilfgaardians here, so try to get to here and kill the Nilfgaardian's as fast as possible. The quest will fail if the player does not save Ves in time. |
| 4 | There will be 7 Nilfgaardian soldiers in the way to Ves and 5 more that is fighting Ves. |
| 5 | Choose to kill or spare the surviving soldier. It will not have any gameplay nor story impact. |
Should I Kill or Spare the Soldier?
At the end of the quest, Geralt can decide whether or not Roche should kill the surviving Nilfgaardian soldier.
Kill the Soldier
Roche uses Ves' sword and takes responsibilty by killing the soldier.
Let the Soldier Live
Roche lets the soldier go. He proceeds to tell the rest of the ability of the Temerian Guerillas.
Best Choice
Either of the Choices
This choice has no effect or consequence on the gameplay nor the story, letting the player choose whatever they think is appropriate.
An Eye for an Eye Tips and Strategies
Saving Ves
If you have trouble getting to Ves before she dies to the Nilfgaardians, you can call and ride Roach instead of running to her. You can ride past the first 7 soldiers in the way to get to Ves straight away.
Hanged Man's Venom Oil will be usefull for extra damage. Blizzard Potion is also good as there are multiple enemies in a small area, making it easier to chain the effect of the potion.
When fighting the soldiers, focus on the ranged arbalists first. They take less hits to kill and will make it harder for you to fight against the melee soldiers as they will continuesly shoot bolts at you during the fight.
Is An Eye for an Eye Worth It?
An Eye for an Eye is Worth It
Completing this quest will make Roche and Ves available to help in the main quest The Battle for Kaer Morhen. You will also need to complete this quest and the side quests A Deadly Plot and Redania's Most Wanted to be able to unlock the side quest Reason of State. The quest Reason of State will let you decide the outcome of the war and will even let you affect Ciri's ending.
The Witcher 3 Related Links
All Secondary Quests
Base Game Secondary Quests
| At the Mercy of Strangers (N/A) | A Mysterious Passenger | Gwent Quest: Collect ‘em All! (N/A) |
| Gwent Quest: Old Pals (N/A) | Never Trust Children (N/A) | A Frying Pan, Spick and Span (N/A) |
| Missing in Action (N/A) | Precious Cargo (N/A) | Twisted Firestarter (N/A) |
| Caravan Attack (N/A) | Deadly Crossing (N/A) | Face Me if You Dare! (N/A) |
| Fake Papers (N/A) | Gwent Quest: Velen Players (N/A) | Harassing a Troll (N/A) |
| Highway Robbery (N/A) | Highwayman's Cache (N/A) | Looters (N/A) |
| Man's Best Friend (N/A) | Races: Crow's Perch (N/A) | The Truth is in the Stars (N/A) |
| A Warm Welcome (N/A) | Drunken Rabble (N/A) | Empty Coop (N/A) |
| Gwent Quest: Big City Players (N/A) | Gwent Quest: Playing Innkeeps (N/A) | Gwent Quest: Playing Thaler (N/A) |
| Call of the Wild (N/A) | Karmic Justice (N/A) | The Four Faces of Hemdall (N/A) |
| The Heroes' Pursuits: For the Goddess' Glory (N/A) | The Heroes' Pursuits: Kaer Trolde (N/A) | Message from an Old Friend (N/A) |
| Woe is Me (N/A) | Worthy of Trust (N/A) | Novigrad, Closed City (II) (N/A) |
| Trail of Echoes (N/A) | Race: The Great Erasmus Vegelbud Memorial Derby (N/A) | Racists of Novigrad (N/A) |
| Strangers in the Night (N/A) | Strumpet in Distress (N/A) | Suspicious Shakedown (N/A) |
| The Flame of Hatred (N/A) | The Most Truest of Basilisks (N/A) | The Price of Passage (N/A) |
| Yustianna Disturbed | The Heroes' Pursuits: Fyresdal | The Heroes' Pursuits: Fayrlund |
| Siren's Call | Farting Trolls | Brave Fools Die Young |
| Witch Hunter Raids (N/A) | Gwent Quest: Skellige Style (N/A) | On Death's Bed (2) |
| The Dwarven Document Dilemma (2) | Funeral Pyres (3) | Hazardous Goods (4) |
| The Whispering Hillock (5) | A Dog's Life (5) | Ciri's Room (5) |
| A Favor for a Friend (6) | A Towerful of Mice (6) | An Invitation from Keira Metz (6) |
| Fools' Gold (6) | Ghosts of the Past (6) | Magic Lamp (6) |
| The Fall of the House of Reardon (6) | Hey, You Wanna Look at my Stuff? (6) | A Greedy God (7) |
| Forefathers' Eve (7) | Lynch Mob (7) | Thou Shalt Not Pass (7) |
| Wild at Heart (7) | Haunted House (7) | For the Advancement of Learning (8) |
| Hidden Messages of the Nilfgaardian Kind (8) | Novigrad Hospitality (8) | Bitter Harvest (9) |
| Last Rites (9) | Return to Crookback Bog (9) | Honor Among Thieves (9) |
| Of Dairy and Darkness (9) | The Gangs of Novigrad (9) | Death By Fire (10) |
| Defender of the Faith (10) | Love's Cruel Snares (10) | Witcher Wannabe (10) |
| Rough Neighborhood (10) | Following the Thread (11) | Fists of Fury: Velen (11) |
| A Barnful of Trouble (11) | Novigrad, Closed City (11) | Fists of Fury: Champion of Champions (11 ) |
| Blood Ties (12) | A Dangerous Game (12) | A Matter of Life and Death (12) |
| A Walk on the Waterfront (12) | An Eye for an Eye (12) | Fencing Lessons (12) |
| Redania's Most Wanted (12) | Spooked Mare (12) | Flesh for Sale (12 ) |
| Black Pearl (13) | A Tome Entombed (13) | From a Land Far, Far Away (13) |
| The Volunteer (13) | Warehouse of Woe (13 ) | Free Spirit (13) |
| A Deadly Plot (14) | Cabaret (14) | Master of the Arena (14) |
| Stranger in a Strange Land (14) | The Cave of Dreams (14) | Now or Never (14) |
| Out On Your Arse! (14) | The Nobleman Statuette (14) | The Soldier Statuette (14) |
| The Price of Honor (14 ) | The Nithing (14) | A Bard's Beloved (15) |
| Armed Assault (15) | For Fame and Glory (15) | Little Red (15) |
| The Family Blade (15 ) | In Wolf's Clothing (15 ) | An Unpaid Debt (15 ) |
| The Last Wish (15) | Carnal Sins (16) | The Path of Warriors (16) |
| The Lord of Undvik (17) | Possession (17) | Crime and Punishment (18) |
| King's Gambit (18) | Coronation (18) | Iron Maiden (19) |
| A Feast for Crows (20) | Hard Times (21) | Brothers In Arms: Velen (22) |
| Brothers In Arms: Novigrad (22) | Brothers In Arms: Skellige (22) | Brothers In Arms: Nilfgaard (22) |
| Fists of Fury: Novigrad (23) | The Bastion (23 ) | Abandoned Sawmill (24) |
| Finders Keepers (24) | Shock Therapy (24) | Of Swords and Dumplings (24) |
| Master Armorers (24) | Practicum in Advanced Alchemy (24 ) | Take What You Want (25) |
| Where the Cat and Wolf Play... (25) | Peace Disturbed (25) | Taken as a Lass (25 ) |
| A Final Kindness (26) | High Stakes (26) | The Sad Tale of the Grossbart Brothers (26) |
| Monster Slayer (26) | Greenhouse Effect (27) | Berengar's Blade (27 ) |
| It Takes Three to Tango (28) | Faithful Friend (30) | Fists of Fury: Skellige (30) |
| Reason of State (30) | The Tower Outta Nowheres (30 ) | The Witcher's Forge (30 ) |
Blood and Wine Secondary Quests
| Fists of Fury: Toussaint | Mutual of Beauclair's Wild Kingdom | The Words of the Prophets are Written on Sarcophagi |
| Till Death Do You Part | Using Your Loaf | Vintner's Contract: Chuchote Cave |
| Vintner's Contract: Duchaton Crest | Of Sheers and a Witcher I Sing | Big Feet to Fill: The Third Group |
| Big Feet to Fill | Gwent Quest: Never Fear, Skellige’s Here! (N/A) | No Place Like Home (Blood and Wine) (N/A) |
| Big Feet to Fill: The Second Group (N/A) | Big Feet to Fill: The First Group (N/A) | Amidst the Mill's Grist (N/A) |
| A Knight’s Tales | Raging Wolf | Knight for Hire |
| Extreme Cosplay | Big Feet to Fill: The Fourth Group | The Perks of Being a Jailbird |
| Big Feet to Fill: The Fifth Group | The Warble of a Smitten Knight (35) | Turn and Face the Strange (35) |
| Paperchase (36) | Goodness, Gracious, Great Balls of Granite! (36) | Wine Wars: Vermentino (37) |
| Wine Wars: Coronata (37) | Father Knows Worst (37) | Wine Wars: Belgaard (37 and 39) |
| Vintner's Contract: Rivecalme Storehouse (37) | Gwent Quest: To Everything - Turn, Turn, Tournament! (38) | Vintner's Contract: Dun Tynne Hillside (40) |
| Wine Wars: Consorting (40) | Master Master Master Master! (40) | Wine Wars: The Deus in the Machina (42) |
| The Hunger Game (42) | Vintner's Contract: Cleaning Those Hard-to-Reach Places (43) | There Can Be Only One (43) |
| A Portrait of the Witcher as an Old Man (43) | Duck, Duck, Goosed! (47) |
Hearts of Stone Secondary Quests
| Enchanting: Quality Has Its Price (32) | Enchanting: Start-up Costs (32) | Races: Swift as the Western Winds (32) |
| The Taxman Cometh (32) | Without a Trace (32) | A Midnight Clear (33) |
| Rose on a Red Field (33) | Avid Collector (34) |
Comment
Author
An Eye for an Eye Walkthrough, Choices and Best Choice
Rankings
Gaming News
Popular Games
Genshin Impact Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Honkai: Star Rail Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Arknights: Endfield Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Umamusume: Pretty Derby Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Wuthering Waves Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Pokemon TCG Pocket (PTCGP) Strategies & Guides Wiki
Abyss Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Zenless Zone Zero Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Digimon Story: Time Stranger Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Recommended Games
Fire Emblem Heroes (FEH) Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl (BDSP) Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Diablo 4: Vessel of Hatred Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Monster Hunter World Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Persona 3 Reload Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
Cyberpunk 2077: Ultimate Edition Walkthrough & Guides Wiki
All rights reserved
The Witcher® is a trademark of CD PROJEKT S. A. The Witcher game © CD PROJEKT S. A. All rights reserved. The Witcher game is based on the prose of Andrzej Sapkowski. All other copyrights and trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
The copyrights of videos of games used in our content and other intellectual property rights belong to the provider of the game.
The contents we provide on this site were created personally by members of the Game8 editorial department.
We refuse the right to reuse or repost content taken without our permission such as data or images to other sites.