Should You Tell Agatha?

Agatha will ask you about the Noontide attack during the Wishful Thinking main mission of STALKER 2: Heart of Chornobyl. Read on to learn if you should tell Agatha about the attack as well as the consequences and results of each choice.

Tell Agatha Choice Results

Agatha Will Already Know About the Attack

Choices	Results
The experiment is in danger.	You tell Agatha about Spark and Noontide but it will not affect the result of the Noontide assault, later on.
I don't know anything.	Agatha remains silent but she plays a recording of Strider contacting you about the presence of the Monolith in SIRCAA. However, this will not affect the result of the Noontide assault, later on.

Telling Agatha about the Noontide assault on SIRCAA is a choice that occurs during the main mission, Wishful Thinking. Regardless of what you tell her, events will play out the same way since Agatha already knows about the Noontide attack and she is only testing your loyalties at this stage of the main story.

The Noontide and Ward Choice Later On is More Important

However, do note that there will be a much more important choice during Wishful Thinking where you have to choose between siding with Noontide or the Ward. Your choice here will determine the main missions you receive after you escape SIRCAA.

When talking to Dubny, choosing I'm with you will have you working closely with Spark after the events in SIRCAA. Choosing I'm with the Ward will ally you with the Ward. However, do note that you can change allegiances later on once you reach the main mission, Subtle Matter.

Should You Tell Agatha?

Tell Her About the Attack if You Plan to Side with Ward

If you plan to fully side with Ward during your playthrough, then you can choose to warn Agatha about the attack. However, do note that this does not affect the story outcome in any way since she already knows. This choice is purely for roleplaying purposes since the major choice in Wishful Thinking happens later in the mission.

How to Side With Ward

Don't Tell Her About the Attack if You Want to Help Strider

If you plant to help the Noontiders, then don't tell Agatha about the attack. Again, this won't really affect the outcome of the mission since the signal that reverts the Noontiders back to Monolithians will always occur regardless of what you choose or who you side with.

STALKER 2 Related Guides

List of All Choices

Choice Guides