| Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Gameplay & Story | Release Date | Pre-Order & DLC | Review |
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club combines classic detective work with modern visuals. Read our review to see what it did well, what it didn’t do well, and if it's worth buying.
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Review Overview
What is Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club?
Emio: Famicom Detective Club is primarily a visual novel, where the narrative and visuals are the main driving force behind the experience, with gameplay revolving around point-and-click and dialogue/action choices. As a sequel to the over 30-year-old series, it features modern enhancements to enrich the inquisitive and thought-provoking gameplay.
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club features:
⚫︎ Immersive Detective Work
⚫︎ Engaging Mystery
⚫︎ Rich Narrative
⚫︎ Modern Visuals
⚫︎ Character-Specific Perspectives
⚫︎ Intricate Review Mechanic
⚫︎ Interactive Dialogue Choices
For more gameplay details, read everything we know about Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club's gameplay and story.
| Digital Storefronts | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Switch |
|||||
| Price | $49.99 | ||||
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
 Detailed Notebook Engaging Review Mechanic Atmospheric Visuals and Cutscenes Multiple Playable Characters |
Frustrating Progression Blocks Inconsistent Audio Design Unbalanced Character Dynamics Limited Replay Value |
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Overall Score - 78/100
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club offers a compelling mystery that successfully blends classic detective elements with modern visual novel gameplay. The story is undoubtedly the strongest aspect, pulling you into a dark and complex narrative filled with twists and turns. The gameplay, while solid, does have its moments of frustration, particularly when the flow is interrupted by illogical progression blocks. Visually, the game is polished, effectively conveying the atmosphere of suspense and tension. However, the audio occasionally misses the mark, detracting from the overall experience. Despite its flaws, Emio provides good value for money, delivering a memorable experience that fans of the genre will appreciate.
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Story - 9/10
The story of Emio is the game’s most compelling feature, earning it a high score. The narrative is rich and layered, drawing you in from the very beginning with its intriguing premise. The mystery at the heart of the game is well-crafted, keeping you engaged as you uncover clues and piece together the puzzle. In addition to the central mystery, the story also delves into themes of grief, particularly seen through the reactions of Eisuke’s peers following his death and in Detective Kazu’s struggles when confronted with her past. These emotional layers add depth to the narrative, making it more than just a simple whodunit. While the characters may not be the primary reason you stay invested, the plot itself is strong enough to carry the experience. It’s a story that hooks you and keeps you guessing, with enough twists to keep even seasoned mystery fans on their toes.
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Gameplay - 7/10
The gameplay in Emio is what you would expect from a visual novel game with a detective twist. The puzzles are engaging, and the process of finding clues and solving the mystery is fairly solid. However, it’s not without its flaws. The mechanics can sometimes be frustrating, particularly when progression is blocked by unclear objectives or illogical actions. The "Think" mechanic, while helpful at times, can also add to the confusion. Despite these issues, the core gameplay is enjoyable and provides a satisfying sense of accomplishment when you finally unravel the mystery.
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Visuals - 8/10
Visually, Emio is a solid and polished game. The characters convey their emotions effectively, particularly during moments of suspicion or tension. The art style is clean, and the cutscenes, especially those that delve into darker narrative elements like flashbacks or the legend of Emio, are well-executed and enhance the mystery. These visual touches contribute significantly to the game’s atmosphere, immersing you in the eerie world of Emio. However, there are moments where the visuals, while strong, could have pushed the boundaries further to elevate the experience even more.
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Audio - 7/10
Audio is where Emio falls a bit short. While the sound design is generally competent, the music often feels out of place, especially during conversations where the background score seems more suited to a slice-of-life scenario than a tense mystery. That said, there are moments when the audio shines, particularly when the music stops to let the dialogue stand on its own, enhancing the gravity of the situation. These moments show the potential of the audio design, but overall, it doesn’t consistently support the game’s dark and mysterious tone.
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Value for Money - 8/10
At a price point of $49.99, Emio offers good value for money, especially considering its place in a legendary franchise. While the game may not have much in the way of replay value, the experience it provides is worthwhile for fans of the genre. The depth of the story and the complexity of the mystery make it a game that is worth the investment, even if it’s a one-time playthrough. For those who appreciate a well-crafted narrative and are willing to overlook some gameplay flaws, Emio delivers a satisfying experience that justifies its price.
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Review: A Fascinating Case with Persistent Flaws
As I mentioned in the demo review, Emio is my first experience with the Famicom Detective Club series, but I’m well aware of its legacy in the visual novel genre. After trying out the demo, I was cautiously optimistic about the full release, and I’m glad I approached it that way. While Emio delivers a solid mystery narrative, some of its gameplay mechanics remain frustrating, even as the story unfolds with intriguing complexity.
Let’s start with those frustrating aspects. In the demo, I pointed out that the gameplay hinges on interacting with people and your surroundings to find clues and progress. Unfortunately, the issue of illogical progression blocks persists throughout most of the game. The "Think" mechanic, which is intended to provide the character's inner monologue and nudge you in the right direction, sometimes feels more like an additional layer of confusion.
There were moments when the "Think" option would unexpectedly prompt a continuation of the other character's thoughts instead of offering helpful introspection. It’s not that this is inherently bad game design—overall, the gameplay is relatively smooth—but it can definitely be frustrating when you’re left wondering, "What am I supposed to do next?"
One of the things that also irked me was some of the interactions, particularly when playing as Ayumi. Emio offers the opportunity to play not just as the male protagonist but also as Ayumi, the other assistant private investigator. I liked Ayumi as a character—she’s kind and determined—but the way she’s treated by other characters often felt patronizing. People frequently commented on how "cute" she is, and it never seemed like she was being taken as seriously as the main protagonist.
There’s one scene where Ayumi follows a lead with Fukuyama, only to discover he doesn’t have anything new to share and simply wants to share a milk tea. While the scene eventually contributes to the investigation, the whole interaction felt like it was detracting from the central mystery. There are more moments like this throughout the game, not just when playing as Ayumi, which sometimes left me confused—is this game supposed to be a mystery, or are we trying to do something else here?
Despite these annoyances, I can understand why some characters were written the way they were. Their behavior adds layers of suspicion and tension, even if it sometimes crosses into irritation. On the positive side, one thing Emio does exceptionally well is planting narrative seeds that eventually lead to crucial clues. In the demo, I expressed my dissatisfaction with the "Review" mechanic, but in the full game, it turned out to be one of my favorite features. What initially felt like hand-holding transformed into a satisfying challenge. The "Review" segments require you to have a firm grasp of every detail gathered so far, allowing you to solve the puzzle by recapping everything you’ve learned. Although, I do wish there were some sort of penalty for getting something wrong, rather than simply being sent back to rethink your approach.
The story of Emio is undoubtedly its strongest suit. The narrative is so engaging that it drives you to push forward, even when the gameplay falters. What makes Emio stand out is that it’s not just about solving a single mystery but unraveling a series of interconnected cases. The primary narrative focuses on the murder of Eisuke Sasaki, a boy found with an ominous paper bag over his head. As the investigation progresses, we delve into the cases of Ayaka Hashizume, Mika Inoue, and Sachiko Takagi—teenage girls who were murdered 18 years ago in a similar fashion to Eisuke.
Adding to the intrigue is the urban legend of Emio, a sinister figure said to appear to young girls in distress, offering them a "forever smile" before taking their lives. But the mystery doesn’t end there. There’s also the question of Detective Kazu’s past and how it might tie into the events of both the present and the past. Emio successfully weaves these elements together, creating a complex and compelling narrative that keeps you guessing.
In summary, while Emio may stumble in its execution with some frustrating gameplay mechanics and character interactions, the rich and engaging story more than makes up for it. It’s a game that demands your attention and rewards your patience with a multi-layered mystery that’s as satisfying to uncover as it is challenging to solve.
Pros of Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club
| Things Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Got Right |
|---|
|
Detailed Notebook Engaging Review Mechanic Atmospheric Visuals and Cutscenes Multiple Playable Characters |
Detailed Notebook
The notebook in Emio is one of the standout features that significantly enhances the gameplay experience. Every piece of information you uncover about the characters, locations, and events is meticulously recorded here, with key details thoughtfully underlined. This allows you to easily reference crucial information as you progress through the game, making it an invaluable tool for solving the mystery. The detailed nature of the notebook not only helps in keeping track of the myriad clues but also adds a layer of immersion, as it feels like you’re truly stepping into the shoes of a diligent detective.
Moreover, the way the notebook is organized reflects the thoroughness required in a real investigation. It’s not just about finding clues but about understanding their relevance and how they connect to the larger mystery. This level of detail encourages you to pay close attention to every conversation and observation, knowing that even the smallest piece of information could be the key to cracking the case. The notebook, in this sense, becomes more than just a passive record—it’s an active part of your investigative toolkit.
Engaging Review Mechanic
One of the more engaging aspects of Emio is the Review/Puzzle mechanic that occurs at the end of each investigation session. This feature requires you to thoroughly review what you’ve gathered, ensuring that you’ve absorbed every detail before moving on. It’s a great way to reinforce the narrative and keeps you actively involved in the story. The game challenges you to recall specific pieces of information, often requiring you to pull answers directly from your notebook. This mechanic transforms what could have been a simple recap into a satisfying mental exercise, where your attention to detail is rewarded.
Additionally, there are moments when you’re asked to type out answers, adding a layer of interactivity that’s both fun and rewarding. This aspect of the gameplay feels like a test of your detective skills, and when you get it right, it’s incredibly satisfying. It’s not just about passively reading through text; you’re required to engage with the material actively, which makes the whole experience more immersive and enjoyable. This mechanic ties in perfectly with the game’s overall theme of mystery and investigation, making you feel like you’re truly piecing together the puzzle.
Atmospheric Visuals and Cutscenes
The visual presentation in Emio is another significant strength that deserves mention. The game’s art style is polished, with a clear attention to detail in character expressions, which are especially effective in conveying suspicion, tension, and fear. The cutscenes, particularly those that delve into darker narrative elements, like flashbacks or the legend of Emio, are striking and enhance the overall mystery. These visual elements work in harmony to create a suspenseful atmosphere that draws you deeper into the story.
The cutscenes are not just visually appealing but are also crucial in setting the tone for the game. They effectively use color, lighting, and pacing to create moments of high tension and eerie calm, which keeps you on edge as the story unfolds. These scenes serve as visual punctuation marks that highlight key moments in the narrative, ensuring that they leave a lasting impression.
Multiple Playable Characters
Emio offers the unique experience for the series, of letting you play as multiple characters. This feature adds depth to the storytelling as you get to see the mystery unfold from different perspectives. This variety in perspective not only enriches the narrative but also adds a layer of complexity to the gameplay, as different characters have different interactions with the people and environments they encounter. Moreover, this feature allows the game to explore different facets of the story that might be inaccessible from a single character's point of view.
Cons of Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club
| Things That Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Can Improve |
|---|
|
Frustrating Progression Blocks Inconsistent Audio Design Unbalanced Character Dynamics Limited Replay Value |
Frustrating Progression Blocks
One of the most significant drawbacks of Emio is the frequent frustration caused by illogical progression blocks. There are moments in the game where you can get stuck, not because of a challenging puzzle, but due to unclear objectives or arbitrary triggers that prevent you from moving forward. This issue can be particularly vexing because it disrupts the flow of the game and breaks immersion. For instance, you might find yourself revisiting the same location or re-engaging in the same dialogue multiple times, trying to trigger the next event. This trial-and-error approach to progression feels outdated and can detract from the overall experience, making it more of a chore than a challenge.
Moreover, these progression blocks can create a sense of disconnection between the player and the story. When you’re engrossed in the narrative and suddenly hit a wall, it pulls you out of the experience and can make the pacing feel uneven. This is especially disappointing in a game that otherwise excels in creating a cohesive and immersive mystery. The frustration of not knowing what to do next, even when you’ve seemingly exhausted all options, can lead to a sense of burnout, which is a shame given how engaging the rest of the game is.
Inconsistent Audio Design
The audio design in Emio is another area where the game falters. While there are moments when the music and sound effects effectively enhance the atmosphere, these instances are unfortunately sporadic. More often than not, the background music feels mismatched with the scenes, leaning more toward a slice-of-life vibe than the tense, suspenseful tone that a mystery game demands. This inconsistency can be jarring, particularly during key investigative moments when the music fails to build the necessary tension.
Additionally, the sound design lacks variety, with some tracks feeling repetitive and others failing to leave a memorable impact. This can be particularly disappointing during moments of revelation or climax in the story, where a powerful audio cue could have significantly heightened the emotional impact. While the audio isn’t bad per se, it doesn’t consistently rise to the level needed to fully support the game’s dark and mysterious atmosphere, which is a missed opportunity in an otherwise well-crafted narrative experience.
Unbalanced Character Dynamics
Another con is the way certain character dynamics are handled, particularly regarding the portrayal of Ayumi. While it’s great that the game offers multiple playable characters, the way Ayumi is treated by other characters can sometimes be grating. This issue isn’t just limited to dialogue but also manifests in certain interactions that feel out of place in a mystery-focused game. For instance, when Ayumi is on a lead with Fukuyama, the scene devolves into an awkward moment over a milk tea, which feels like it’s detracting from the central mystery.
These moments contribute to a sense of inconsistency in the narrative, as they shift the focus away from the investigation and toward less relevant character interactions. While these scenes might be intended to add depth or lighten the mood, they can instead come across as distracting and even patronizing. The game sometimes struggles to balance the serious tone of the mystery with these lighter, less relevant interactions, leading to a jarring experience that can pull players out of the story.
Limited Replay Value
Finally, Emio suffers from limited replay value. Once you’ve completed the game and uncovered the mystery, there’s little incentive to go back and replay it. While the story is engaging, it’s also linear, with no, branching paths or alternative endings that would encourage multiple playthroughs. This isn’t uncommon in visual novel-style games, but it does mean that Emio is likely to be a one-and-done experience for most players.
This limitation is particularly notable given the price point of the game. While the initial playthrough offers a rich and rewarding experience, the lack of replayability might leave some players feeling like they didn’t get the full value for their money. It’s a game that, once completed, might not hold much appeal for a second go, which could be a downside for those who enjoy games with lasting appeal or the ability to uncover new content in subsequent playthroughs.
Is Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Worth It?
Worthwhile Detective Journey
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club offers a compelling and immersive experience for fans of the mystery and visual novel genres, making it a worthwhile investment despite some imperfections. The game excels in delivering a richly woven narrative that hooks you from start to finish, with its intricate plot and engaging character arcs. The detailed notebook and review mechanics provide a satisfying depth to the investigation process, enhancing the overall gameplay experience.
The atmospheric visuals and engaging story significantly outweigh these concerns, ensuring that the time spent with the game is both enjoyable and rewarding. For those who appreciate a well-crafted visual novel, Emio is definitely worth the investment. The game builds on the promising elements showcased in the demo, making it a solid choice for anyone looking to delve into a classic detective adventure that rewards patience.
| Digital Storefronts | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Switch |
|||||
| Price | $49.99 | ||||
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club FAQ
Is Emio: Famicom Detective Club Available In Physical Copy?
Yes, you can purchase a physical copy of the game through the links below:
| Physical Retailers | |||
|---|---|---|---|
 Best Buy |
Switch |
||
| Price | $49.99 | ||
What Language Does Emio: Famicom Detective Club Support?
Emio’s audio is only available in Japanese, but the interface and subtitles are provided in Japanese, English, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Korean, and Chinese.
Game8 Reviews
You may also like...
Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Product Information
 | |
| Title | EMIO – THE SMILING MAN: FAMICOM DETECTIVE CLUB |
|---|---|
| Release Date | August 29, 2024 |
| Developer | Nintendo |
| Publisher | Nintendo |
| Supported Platforms | Nintendo Switch |
| Genre | Horror, Visual Novel |
| Number of Players | 1 |
| Rating | ESRB M17+ |
| Official Website | Emio Official Website |
